involves more science
than you knew
So you’re going to change the oil in your bike…. Great
decision! There is little maintenance as
important as keeping fresh oil in that engine.
But which brightly colored can of oil should you be using? It seems like everyone you talk to has a
different opinion of what's best for your bike.
Here we’ll cover the science that goes into motor oil, and
help you make an informed choice when buying that sweet black gold.
Grades vs. Groups
In order to make an informed purchase you should have a
basic understanding of what’s actually in a quart of oil. Basically, there are two primary
classifications of motor oil that you should be aware of; grades, and groups. The grade refers to the oils
weight (viscosity), while the group is the chemical makeup of the oil.
Grade/ Weight (Viscosity
ratings)
Oil is rated on its label by weight, (ex. 15w40) this is to
let you know just how viscous the oil is.
(the higher the number, the thicker the oil) There is allot more to this number, however, than most know. For starters, the “w”
stands for “winter” not “weight.” This
is because multi-grade oils (oils with two weights) are rated for two different
temperatures. The first number is the
oil’s cold start weight, measured at 0 degrees celsius; while the second number
is the oil’s weight at running temps, measured at 100 degrees celsius.
These multi-grade oils are created by adding magical molecules
chains, called viscosity index improvers(VII’s).
The VII’s work their magic by curling up
small when their cold, and stretching out when their hot.
This allows the oil to behave differently
at varying temps.
The amount of VII’s
that go into an oil then, control how large the spread is between the two numbers.
The amount of VII's is stated as the VII factor, which is simply the quotient of the two weights.
Example: a 10w40 oil has a VII factor of 4
(10/40=4). Make sense?
The VII factor is important because these VII’s can break down under the pressure and churning that normally occurs in a motorcycle engine. Because VII's act to thicken a naturally thin oil, VII break down lowers the high temp viscosity and inhibits the oils ability to lubricate a hot engine. Its been shown that under normal running conditions, a non-synthetic 10w40 can actually be reduced to a 10w25 in as little as 1,000 miles. For this reason, non-synthetic oils with a
VII factor of 4 or more should not be ran in motorcycles for more than 1,500
miles.
Single grade oil, on the other hand, is very straightforward
stuff. One weight, tested at 100 degrees
celsius, and no VII’s. This can be the
right choice if your bike lives somewhere with very consistent temperatures,
and is always given ample time to warm up before riding. Without any VII’s, single grade oil offers a longer life and offers a more consistent high temp viscosity.
(use wisely)
Note* oil weights represent a small range of viscosity, so one 40 weight may be slightly heavier or lighter than another.
Oil Groups
Oils are further Grouped as type 1 through 5, based on the
way they are refined and what they come from. All non-synthetic
motor oil comes from liquefied dinosaurs, which is sucked out of the dirt. This crude oil is often lousy with paraffin
wax, tar, and aromatics. (all bad things)

- Type 1 oil is basically just dino juice strained
through clay and solvents. This leaves
type 1 oil with a about 15% wax and tar content, and only about 85% good engine
protecting oil. This should only be put in your bike under apocalyptic circumstances. Type 2 and 3 oils are
further refined using a De-Waxing process that significantly increases the
yield of pure oil.
- Type 2 oil uses a distilling method to remove
nearly three times more wax and tar than the type 1 method. The resulting type 2 oil has a only about 3%
impurities and 97% good stuff. This is still not good enough for your bike.
- Type 3 oil is far and away the purest of the dino
juice categories, and was only developed in the late 90’s. Type 3 oils use a chemical De-Waxing method
to remove virtually all wax and tar, allowing them to be run for more miles and
protect better. Type 3 oils perform
comparable to synthetic oils at running temps, and are even marketed as
“Synthetic.” (if you're paying less than $12 a quart you're probably using a type 3 oil)
- Oil producers have attempted to overcome the slight shortcomings of type 3 oils by blending with true synthetic oil. However, even a blend cannot fully match a true synthetic.
- Type 4 and 5 oils are commonly referred to as
synthetic oils. Basically the difference
in the two lies in where their base oil comes from. While type 4 base oil starts with a chemical
called olefin, type 5 starts with plant and animal based cooking oils. It looks like in the near future we will also
be seeing a type 6 created from liquid natural gas. These base oils then go through an intensive process of mixing chemicals and bonding molecules, to create a man mad motor oil. Group 4-6 oils all seem to perform the same,
but differ in production cost of their base oil. Synthetic oil has enormous advantages since
it is chemically engineered for the specific task. Synthetic oil has superior film strength, allowing for safer starts; better low temp performance without the need for high VII content; a higher flash point, protecting you at redline rpm's; as well as lower oxidation and acid buildup.
Lastly, Additive
Packages
Its important to note that oil producers place a wide
variety of additives in their oil such as solvents, buffers, detergents, and
additional lubricants. While
these additives serve a purpose, it’s important to keep in mind that not every
additive package is suitable for every engine.
For example, 0w-20, 5w-30, and 10w-30 non-synthetic oils are termed energy
conserving, meant for small cars, and should not be used with a wet clutch. EVER!
So we now have a pretty good list of non-synthetic oils you
should NOT be running in your bike: 0w20, 5w20, 5w30, & 10w30 can cause
clutch problems when ran in a wet clutch due to their additives; 5w20, 5w30,
& 10w40 breaks down quickly due to a very high VII content; and all single
grade oils should be used with caution.
So what’s left?
Well basically you’re left with 15w30, 15w40, 20w50, or a
25w60. (Note* a true synthetic 10w30, or
10w40 is safe as well)
So What Grade Oil Should You Use?
It’s best to use the grade of oil recommended in
your owners manual.
This can become
difficult, however, when you're riding in conditions wildly outside of what the
bike was designed for (ex. riding a 60s’ British bike in Arizona), when you don't have an owners manual, or when the bike
manufacturer attempts to hide this information so you’ll use their brand of
oil.
The grade of motor oil called for to be used in your bike is based on some specific engineering that went into your bike, as well as the temps it was expected to operate in. There is some room for you to make changes, but it's important that you do it right. Based on high temp shear viscosity tests, there are really only three choices for high temp oil weights:
High temp weight
- 20
- 30 - light 40
- heavy 40 - 60.
Basically all the high temp weights within a particular line will behave about the same. So you could switch from a 50 up to a 60 if your spring to summer weather fluctuates drastically. However, you should NOT switch between weights in different lines. (cannot go from 30 to 50)
For the low temp weight, its really about film protection and protecting your bike during warm up. For this reason you have a little more room to decide whats best for your bike, however remember what we talked about earlier regarding VII's. For the low temp you want an oil thats liquid enough to pump around the bike when you hit the start button, without being so thin that you sacrifice film protection. A 5w will be safe to start as low as -13 degrees fahrenheit, while a 20w is only safe down to about 30 degrees fahrenheit.
Be smart about this, and don't test out a new weight oil in your bike with a 2,000 mile trip.
I have also created a couple tables to help out Harley
owners:
Here's a couple vids covering the process of
changing your bikes oil:
Special
plug for Fix My Hog. I received their
Harley Maintenance & Performance dvd free from Dennis Kirk, and was
pleasantly surprised. It’s a
comprehensive guide filled with helpful tips.
Sources: